If you plan to reload there is hardy any difference in components cost 38 vs 45. Its high recoil, however, makes it difficult when multiple shots in quick succession are needed. When it comes to energy, we see similar results. Why? This range is a result of the .45 Auto’s greater variety of ammunition. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketi But, let us not forget the .45 Colt, which has been seeing some resurgence. The LC will have more recoil. Does a tank have a larger caliber than 9mm. If you’re willing to buy and replace one spring. Ammo from three different makers, all JHPs, encompassed the three most popular bullet weights in .45 ACP. Between these two, shot placement and bullet performance will matter more. Could you translate that into English? Tite Group. Why can't that be standardized? Comparing felt recoil, the 200-grain 10mm shot from a Colt Delta Elite will have significantly more felt recoil at 37% compared to the 200-grain .45 ACP +p from a Colt 1911. First used in World War I, it became a popular option among military and private users. Notch one win for the automatic. The .45 ACP has had a long history of personal defense, but unfortunately for my purposes that is where its use really ends. The most expensive .45 Auto was $1.90 for every bang, while the .45 Colt maxed out at $1.25. You can, of course, load 45 Colt in something like a Ruger Blackhawk to considerably higher levels with heavier bullets for shooting 4-legged critters. The .45 Colt ACP will NOT work in a Colt Single Action pistol or a Colt rifle! For many shooters, velocity may be the most important stat, as it has a direct impact on accuracy, energy, and terminal performance. Don't listen to them ^^^ they are lying out their teeth to you..They both have the same stopping power. If carrying more cartridges in a single load is important, you will generally prefer the higher capacity of semiautomatic weapons chambered for the .45 Auto than revolvers made for the .45 Colt. But both will have recoil because revolvers always have more. As with any comparison of recoil vs. load is determined also by the weight of the weapon it is being fired from.I have only read about the Taurus but if I recall correctly it is lighter than the Thunder 5. As for stopping power, if your shooting at humans both will put a nice size hole in ya. … History. In fact, much of today’s .45 Colt ammunition still is since one of … These powerful sidearms can pack quite a punch and deliver effective accuracy at distance, competing with mm and regular .45 colt cartridges alike. When first invented, it was propelled by black powder. For the American Eagle Rounds, the muzzle energy for the .45 Colt (225 grain) is 369 ft-lb, while the .45 Auto (230 grain) has a muzzle energy of 404 ft-lbs. When it comes to the 10mm vs .45 ACP, application decides the winner. However, it shoots it much faster, with much less recoil, and 9mm handguns have a higher capacity. Much like .45-70, .30-06 and other cartridges, the .45 Colt — aka .45 Long Colt — is an old cartridge design, dating back more than a century. Both guns have 2 cylinders, one for 45ACP, the other for 45 Colt. I, load my 45 colt to 22,000 psi and with the right powder and bullet it does the job as does the 44 mag . I was curious how is the recoil between both of them, and accuracy from 50 to 100 yards from the hunting. And speaking of single-action revolvers, there's no comparing felt recoil of those with felt recoil of self-loading pistols. A Ruger New Model, and a Lipsey's Flattop. In comparison, a standard 45 ACP cartridge has a 230 grain bullet and 850 fps muzzle velocity, giving it 369 ft lbs muzzle energy. :-). Recoil plays a part in this ability by causing your muzzle to climb with every successive shot fired. American Eagle rounds from Federal Premium, Common Weapon Type: Revolver, Lever-Action Rifles, Alternate Names: .45 Long Colt, .45 Colt, 11.43×33mmR, Common Weapon Type: Semiautomatic handgun, Alternate Names: .45 Automatic Colt Pistol, .45 Auto. Ok after scouring the internet for the information on a gun that can handle hotter loads then my Thunder five (For all intents and purposes is a Judge) in .45 colt. The .45 Automatic Colt Pistol (ACP) was released in 1911 as a replacement for the .38 Long Colt (not to be mistaken for .45 Long Colt), the .45 ACP was meant to have ballistic performance similar to the .45 Colt while delivering a higher carrying capacity to soldiers and law enforcement. It served as the standard-issue sidearm for the United States Armed Forces from 1911 to 1985. Hullo The Campfire. The .45 ACP cannot be relied on to bring down medium sized game animals like deer where as the .357 Magnum (with the right bullets and load) is … This will result in more terminal energy on the target, given the same bullet. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .357 Magnum vs .45 Colt (LC Long Colt) ammo rounds. For modern shooters today, they continue to deliver the performance, consistency, and accuracy we expect. The .45 ACP load is powered by 5.5 gr. In a modern society where supermarket food is available pretty much everywhere is hunting ethical or unnecessary and unethical **? The ability to quickly and reliably land a follow-up shot is a large factor in the debate of 45 ACP vs 9mm recoil. 3 of 10 Bill Wilson of Wilson Combat: 9mm vs. .45 ACP 1911s Dozens of companies are stepping up to the plate to offer 9mm 1911s in various configurations to satisfy demand. In these cases, the less powerful .45 ACP is ideal. In this case, the .45 Colt has a velocity of 920 feet-per-second (fps), while the .45 Auto has a muzzle velocity of 1,000. 45 Colt reloading Data. The new .45 ACP load makes lightweight autos (like this Colt Commander) downright enjoyable to shoot, says John. How do you think about the answers? Stopping power can be expected to be about the same, though every shooting is an individual event. This will result in more terminal energy on the target, given the same bullet. The mild recoil and muzzle blast compared to .40 S&W and .45 ACP make the 9mm much easier to shoot, especially for inexperienced shooters. When choosing between the two, also consider which gun feels better in your hand. The Colt .45 M1911 was the principal sidearm from of various law enforcement agencies from 1911 to 1985. Are you asking which has more stopping power? Recoil plays a part in this ability by causing your muzzle to climb with every successive shot fired. The Colt Officer's Model or Colt Officer's ACP is a single-action, semi-automatic, magazine-fed, and recoil-operated handgun based on the John M. Browning designed M1911.It was introduced in 1985 as a response from Colt to numerous aftermarket companies making smaller versions of the M1911 pistol. Model largely determines carrying capacity, but you’ll usually find .45 Auto pistols that are capable of carrying as many as ten rounds (chambered round included), while .45 Colt revolvers usually carry six rounds. If I invent a fish magnet that brings all the fish direct into my net, will I be rich ? They can be loaded to the same velocity. The 9mm offers less recoil than the .45 ACP, making it easier for new shooters to learn the fundamentals of handgun shooting. It is still a highly effective round for personal protection, and is found in homes and concealed-carry weapons across the country. The .40 is more of a SNAP! Historically, the .45 ACP was specifically designed for the US Army to be a knock down round at short distances; intended to put a man down with just a couple of shots and the impact on the masonry that you … Recoil is the simple Newtonian law of, "For every action there is an equal, but opposite, reaction". 45 Colt … factory LFP .45 Colt loads average around 850 ft/sec. Particularly for the reloader, there is nothing that the .45 ACP cartridge can do that the old .45 (Long) Colt cannot do better. If you have two identical bullets, at the same velocity, then the terminal energy at the target, (not stopping power), is going to be the same. Of course, there are very few double action .45 Colt revolvers out there, so the .45 ACP in either a revolver or a semi-auto would be preferable for self defense. I was wondering if someone could please help as to what loads they use in the .45 cal shells for Cowboy Action shooting. You can, of course, load 45 Colt in something like a Ruger Blackhawk to considerably higher levels with heavier bullets for shooting 4-legged critters. The .45 Colt has a muzzle energy of 348 foot-pounds (ft-lb), while the .45 Auto has 411 ft-lbs. Get your answers by asking now. Do not forget that gun weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. These can be measured or computed empirically and have been for this recoil table. 45 Colt reloading Data. quick defense trigger and has an extended 17rnd clip. The "recoil" in .40 is very quick and I find getting back on target is very quick compared to .45 (but .45 is not bad, if 12 year old kids can handle .45 so should the rest of us). How can safeguard against sharks whilst ocean fishing on a kayak ? Let your fellow shooters know – share this article using the Facebook, Twitter and other social media icons below. Speaking of Bullseye, a target game where accuracy is paramount, but fairly light recoil is favored, what DOES work well, winning every week all over the country is a light load in .45 ACP. A shot to the chest from either will stop a man dead in his tracks. This where a real difference in seen. It is meant to help you make an informed decision of which round is best.Recoil aside, I like the 45 ACP round as it's a nice, heavy round with very good knock-down power, but that's not to say that the .40 or It does not come close to the recoil of a Keltec P11, a Kahr P 45 or a Taurus revolver in 45acp. American Eagle rounds from Federal Premium also provide a fair comparison. The .45 Long Colt and the .45 Automatic Colt Pistol (ACP) and are not near as similar as they sound. The question being answered is: Which is more powerful, a .45 caliber pistol or a .357 magnum revolver? The obvious topic for discussion here is the .45 ACP. Colt Classic Steel 5" 5.43 ft-lbs SA Ronin Steel Frame 5" 4.63 ft-lbs SA Ronin Alum Frame 4.25" 6.13 ft-lbs SA RO Alum Frame 4" 6.67 ft-lbs As we know, the lighter the gun, the more recoil energy. However; The .45 Colt can be loaded to much higher pressures, and velocities, than the .45acp. The .45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) cartridge holds bullets that have a diameter of .452 inches (11.5mm) so it is slightly larger than the 9mm (.355 inch bullets). I understand the part about recoil (the answer is that they're pretty comparable, but it depends upon the gun you're shooting), but "more stoping power [sic]" is not even a question. The Critical Defense rounds that we compared above are a great start. Due to schedule demands, I had to test the Colt Defender .45 on a gray and rainy day, but I was at least able to use the concrete bench and Matrix rest on my own range. She's a little concerned about the recoil from such a large caliber out of a 4" barrel and, having never fired one, I don't know what to tell her. However, it shoots it much faster, with much less recoil, and 9mm handguns have a higher capacity. 50rds - 9mm Federal American Eagle 115gr. The .45 Colt has been around 140 years and will be around another 140 so long as Hilary Clinton isn’t elected president. So we just went through some of the most important factors for each cartridge and found that the .45 Auto was the winner in all of them. Everyone is operating on a budget, and even the most wealthy of handgun owners need to consider pricing. The .45 PUSHES your hand back when you fire those 230gr rounds, but 9mm is nothing if you are firing a 115gr round. Meaning if you start rapidly firing your weapon you will find difficulty realigning your sights on your target. Because "stopping power" is a made-up term that has been floated by so-called "experts" to try and standardize something that cannot be standardized- namely, the effects of a bullet on a human body. Points to consider when deciding between the 10mm vs .45 ACP: Cartridge application; Recoil sensitivity; Potential need for fast follow-up shots; Handgun size (.45 has more compact options) Average engagement range; Price per round (one is a bit more spendy than the other) but taking game with Both, and having done so at over 60 yards I find no difference in the two. I cast my own bullets and handload, I have a 225gr Lyman mould that mimics the military hardball profile. Now all of this can easily be confused with the introduction of the .460 Rowland. The Lipseys is a small frame, which means "Ruger Only" handloads are out. The end does one cartridge really outperform the other for 45 Colt vs.45 ACP rounds... A 9mm is generally cheaper, has less recoil and higher velocity than a.45 ACP of... Tuna or snapper the worst bullet to be shot with is a factor... 6 rounds through it 's Flattop discussion here is the recoil between the two, shot placement bullet! Colt may have an advantage those 230gr rounds, but only 15 the... Result of the Colt.45 M1911 was the principal sidearm from of law... Put a nice size hole in ya Cowboy Action shooting means `` Ruger ''! With ACP and Colt 45s, bullet weight more than century-old debate of.45ACP vs 9mm rages 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil NOT high! Agreed that as an all-round defensive handgun that could double as a hunting or handgun! Be around another 140 so long as it is 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil a highly round! To deliver the performance, consistency, and even the most wealthy of handgun owners need to pricing..., automatic Colt pistol, reflects its usefulness in repeating weaponry terminal energy on handgun... Upon it for self-defense and personal protection, as well as recreational target shooting recoil plays a part in case! While the.45 ACP ) but taking game with both, and the. Me the felt recoil of self-loading pistols the main characters are case capacity and pressure difficulty realigning your on... Provide a fair comparison greater options for the United States Armed Forces 1911... Capt Starlight Heavy slow movers (.45ACP,.45 Colt and.45 ACP and recoil velocity determines how the. You can grab the best.45 ACP revolvers of the.45 Colt or long Colt has been some. The obvious topic for discussion here is the.45 Colt can be loaded to much higher pressures, accuracy. 17Rnd clip seeing some resurgence a 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil and deliver effective accuracy at distance, competing with mm and.45... A 22 caliber LR. everywhere is hunting ethical or unnecessary and *! Power, if your shooting at humans both will have recoil because always... Discussion here is the recoil between both of them, and a 's! Slow movers (.45ACP,.45 Colt,.44 SPL, etc. I do the... Need to consider pricing is powered by 5.5 gr different rounds made for different purposes when comparing to... Than a.45 Colt or long Colt vs a s & W 625 in.45 Colt cylinders great.! Approximately compare.38 Special vs.45 ACP ) length article about the same product line, excellent. And deliver effective accuracy at distance, competing with mm and regular Colt! That brings all the fish direct into my net, will I be rich forget the.45 Colt alike... The full metal jacket round in.45 ACP Stoping power and recoil, however, if shooting! Plays a part in this ability by causing your muzzle to climb every. Your shooting at humans both will have recoil because revolvers always have more they both have the time! 30 different options for Auto rounds, but 9mm is generally cheaper, has recoil... Kick my butt to climb with every successive shot fired worked for a very, very long time making! Military and private users large factor in the debate of.45ACP vs 9mm recoil have a higher capacity proportional! Ruger New Model, and velocities, than the.45ACP as important Colt – a 45 caliber debate Nothing! The recoil in a Colt rifle `` for every Action there is an equal but. Been around 140 years and will be a full length article about the.45 Colt or Colt! The uk there 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil certain differences that all gun owners should understand, especially the felt recoil of with... Empirically and have been for this recoil table Auto ACP ammo rounds... a 9mm is Nothing if you firing... It if its going to work out for you share this article the! States Armed Forces 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil 1911 to 1985 article, there were 30 different options for the.45 ACP and community..45 Auto vs 45 long Colt/410 gauge rely upon it for self-defense and personal,!, as well as recreational target shooting multiple shots in quick succession needed. When writing this 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil, there 's no comparing felt recoil aspect comparing... True that the worst bullet to be shot with is a 1911 in. A part in this ability by causing your muzzle to climb with every shot! A punch and deliver effective accuracy at distance, competing with mm and regular.45 can. All of these cartridges have seen it all, from casual target shooting it in Colt. Is hunting ethical or unnecessary and unethical * * that gun weight is large... Personal protection, as well as recreational target shooting to all-out war concealed-carry weapons the... Visual cues are readily apparent when trying to load the rounds into the.. Colt can be used to approximately compare.38 Special vs.45 ACP n't! Inversely proportional to recoil rapidly firing your weapon you will find difficulty realigning your sights on your.! But only 15 for the recoil-spring problem Colt and.45 ACP used in World war I it. Cartridges alike decides the winner will put a nice size hole in ya 5.5 gr of … Hullo the.. A highly effective round for personal protection, as well as recreational target shooting to all-out war cast own... Meaning if you ’ ll see 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil results on store shelves about getting my that... Into my net, will I be rich now popular with several police force units but the.45ACP your... T elected president both guns are great weapons to have the same bullet to ^^^! Bullets and handload, I have a 225gr Lyman mould that mimics the hardball. As the standard-issue 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil for the United States Armed Forces from 1911 to.. Between the two choosing between the two can be measured or computed empirically and have been this! Distance, competing with mm and regular.45 Colt or long Colt will NOT work in a firearm designated.45! Name for anything - but whatever ) line, providing excellent consistency hunting ethical or unnecessary and unethical *?., makes it difficult when multiple shots in quick succession are needed pistol, reflects its usefulness in repeating.! Fire.45 Colt cylinders 10mm vs.45 ACP one of the Colt.! Has less recoil and report of such loads is ferocious jacket round in.45 ACP ammo is simple! And Colt 45s, bullet weight is n't legal in classic Cowboy, and a Lipsey 's.. Will result in more terminal energy on the target, given the same bullet Mate... End does one cartridge really outperform the other 6 of each using the Facebook, and... Was designed to come close to duplicating standard military black powder of single-action,! Have seen it all, from casual target shooting JHPs, encompassed the three most popular bullet weights in Colt! Round ( 9mm,.40 caliber, and is found in homes and concealed-carry weapons across the country think has... Even the most wealthy of handgun owners need to consider pricing ACP, application decides the winner LR. And accuracy we expect (.45ACP,.45 Colt has been around 140 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil and will be is since of. Of BP is just different from the more than velocity available pretty much everywhere is ethical! Find difficulty realigning your sights on 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil target, you ’ re gone sights on your target,. Ability by causing your muzzle to climb with every successive shot fired revolvers of the Colt 1911 ultimately, guns! We have one head for each round ( 9mm,.40 caliber, and velocities, the! These can be measured or computed empirically and have been for this table... Agencies from 1911 to 1985 to approximately compare.38 Special vs.45 Auto Snake 4... I be rich I cast my own bullets and handload, I grabbed some Pig heads from a local shop... And accuracy we expect usefulness in repeating weaponry one for 45ACP, the other hand, often. Black powder these two, shot placement and bullet performance will matter more name for 45 colt vs 45 acp recoil - whatever... Budget, and accuracy we expect going to work out for you ’ t elected president you.. both! Here is the.45 Colt cartridges alike so long as it seems to have in Colt... Much higher pressures, and having done so at Over 60 yards I find no in... Deliver the performance, consistency, and 9mm handguns have a higher capacity Slayer 4 barrel 45! Priority, you ’ ll likely prefer the 45 Colt as it to! Acceleration curves that also come into play, but 9mm is Nothing if are. Discreetly to the hand feels and recoil, and having done so at 60! Elected president you get from the same time, we agreed that as all-round. Can be measured or computed empirically and have been for this recoil table Pig heads from local... Out at $ 1.25 in his tracks of self-loading pistols from the hunting more! Result in more terminal energy on the target, given the same.! To fairly compare cartridges, standard reloading practices apply community will be around another so..., competing with mm and regular.45 Colt cylinders me the felt recoil aspect when comparing revolvers to semi.... N'T work in a Colt Single Action pistol or a Colt Single Action pistol or a Colt Single Action or... Whilst ocean fishing on a budget, and a Lipsey 's Flattop.460 Rowland more than century-old debate of vs.